When it comes to instrumental albums, I don't often feel tempted by what drummers produce. Not that I have specific bad experiences with drummers' albums or anything, just that it doesn't strike me as an instrument that I want to hear put forward. I did, however, purchase Stanton Moore's III, based partly on a review in MOJO and partly on Moore's pedigree with Galactic and Garage à Trois.
III is a fairly sparse affair with a core band comprised of Stanton Moore on drums, organiste Robert Walter on B3 and guitarist Will Bernard. They are joined on several tracks by the horns of Skerik (saxophones, also of Garage à Trois) and Mark Mullins (trombone). III's repertoire navigates in the waters (no pun intended) of New Orleans traditional and modern music, between funk, jazz, gospel and blues in other words. Some of the pieces are hard to pin into one of these categories, especially the trio efforts which all sound bluesy even when they're funky. The tunes are composed by all three of the collaborators with Robert Walter taking a good share of the lot.
What struck me first about this album is the sound. There's a particular quality to the overall sound, especially - again - the trio pieces. Moore's drumming is quite forward in the mix, louder than you'd expect, but it also sounds increadibly rich in texture, something I found quite unusual and interesting. Walter's organ is greasy and mean, quite distorted and heavier than, say, Jimmy Smith's although the grease is similar. His rhythmic role is impeccable, laying down the soft bass lines that B3 is known for in great synch with Moore's drumming. Bernard's guitar playing, often on slide, is quite mean as well, but sparsely played and all the more efficient for it.
The funkier pieces, especially the ones with the horns, are quite pleasant and get your feet tapping, but they sometimes grow a little repetitive. Big uns get the ball rolling and Chilcock do the trick though, and the latter especially allows Skerik to display his wild sounding tenor playing. I guess though, that these are the kinds of tracks that work best live.
The last three pieces however are stunning and each deserve a mention. Water from an Ancient Wall is an Abdullah Ibrahim original given the New Orleans treatment. You can feel the South African roots, but there's a slice of gospel and a slice of blues in there that are quite moving. Very powerful tune.
Moore and his two acolytes then launch into a superb rendition of Led Zeppelin's When the Levee Breaks. I think jazz covers - especially of pop and rock tunes - work well when they manage to strip the tune to its essential components and rebuild around it, or not as the case may be. This tune is the bare bones of When the Levee Breaks, it's dark, creepy, heavy and powerful and it's impossible, listening to it, not to think of when the New Orleans levee broke, of Katrina and of what New Orleans is now. It's sad, gutwrenching and achingly beautiful at the same time. It's probably one of the most impressive covers I've heard, ever.
But the album doesn't end on that depressing note. It ends on a quietly uplifiting version of the spiritual I Shall Not be Moved, which suggests Moore's determination to continue promoting the music of the city he loves and, more generally, suggests the will of New Orleans to rebuild and retrieve its cultural history that was devastated by the hurricane and the inanity of the local and federal governments.
Ultimately, III is a powerful record even if some tunes, like in every record, are not quite as good as the rest. It's a very accessible record though, as far as instumental exercices go, and despite this it manages a depth of feeling that's quite rare in modern music. It should please both blues, funk and jazz fans and is worth hearing if only for these last three tunes I mentioned.