It's kind of weird to review an album of French rock in English, especially since Noir Désir was such a massive phenomenon in the late 90s and early 00s in France, but it's good music, and I guess if I can listen to albums sung in various languages I know nothing about and enjoy them the same must be possible for non-French speakers with albums in French...
Anyway, I'd pretty much given up on Noir Désir with their last studio album Des Visages, Des Figures which I thought was pretentious and political. I love the early Noir Désir because it's all about the music, but they fell victims to the same syndrom U2 fell to (in my opinion) which is that your music becomes a vehicle for your persona rather than something worthy in and of itself. But when I heard some of the first excerpts from En Public, I started to reconsider, and I don't regret buying it one bit.
It's not every band, especially bands as popular as Noir Désir was back then who can completely reinvent itself live, offer 3 hours of live music that doesn't just cover the singles and famous songs but offer new interpretations and instrumentations of most of their repertoire. The early Noir Désir was atmospheric and evocative. Furious or darkly dreamy, it would always carry you somewhere else with a combination of intelligently poetic lyrics and innovative songwriting.
With En Public, Noir Désir shows that it found itself again towards the end, beyond the public image, the lesson giving and the posturing. They found the ways into their back catalog as well, rewriting songs like Les Ecorchés (as a kind of dark swing), rediscovering Pyromane from their first EP, revisiting the pulsating Le Fleuve with a string quartet.
In many ways, En Public is a fitting end to Noir Désir's career as a band because it's not just representative of a period of the band's life but rather visits their whole lifespan in a really interesting and mature way.
